“I Don’t Trust Him”: Billy Crystal, Social Media, and the Ministry of Silence

There is a moment in Billy Crystal’s recent interview on CBS Sunday Morning that I’ve been reflecting on. Tracy Smith reminds him that in 700 Sundays, Crystal’s Tony-winning show about losing his father at fifteen, he carried on conversations with God. Has he been talking to God these past couple of years?

“No, ’cause I don’t trust Him,” he says. Smith asks if he’s serious. He is.

He explains that too many bad things have happened, that the world is in bad shape, that this is a frightening time. You only need to know his last two years to understand. In January 2025 the Palisades fire took the home his family had lived in for 46 years. That December, his dear friend and longtime collaborator Rob Reiner was killed. The two spent time together just hours before at a late night party.

Now 78, Crystal is back on Broadway with a new one-man show, 860, about loss and the stubborn, healing work of laughter. I think Crystal said something more honest than most of us manage on a Sunday morning.

Honest, Not Faithless

Notice what Crystal did not say. He didn’t say God isn’t there. He didn’t come out as an atheist. You don’t refuse to speak to someone you believe is imaginary. “I don’t trust Him” is the sentence of a man who still knows exactly whom he’s angry with. That isn’t unbelief so much as estrangement, and estrangement is still a relationship.

Crystal is Jewish, and his tradition has a rich vocabulary for this sort of thing. Abraham bargains with God over Sodom. Job demands a hearing. Jeremiah accuses God of deceiving him. At least a third of the Psalms are complaints, and Psalm 88 ends in darkness with no resolution at all.

Scripture doesn’t merely tolerate the argument with God. It preserves it, canonizes it, and sets it to music. “How long wilt thou forget me, O Lord? for ever?” (Psalm 13:1).

C.S. Lewis knew this territory too. After Joy died, he filled the notebooks that became A Grief Observed. He admitted the real danger wasn’t ceasing to believe in God, but coming to believe terrible things about Him; he even let himself wonder whether God was a “Cosmic Sadist.” Readers who knew only The Problem of Pain were startled. Lewis had to learn that answers which seemed air tight from the comfort of his writing chair didn’t hold up from inside a heartbreaking loss.

What carried Lewis through wasn’t an argument someone handed him. It was time, honesty, and a God patient enough to absorb his accusations.

True Words, Wrong Posture

That brings me to a Christian leader with a large following. Posting on X, they noted that everyone suffers loss and disappointment, then said, “But I trust God.” They went on to affirm that God is real and trustworthy, and offered Crystal his advice to trust God with his life and put his faith in Jesus Christ, crucified, and raised.

I believe every one of those sentences. That’s what makes the post so frustrating. True words, offered at the wrong moment and in the wrong posture, become a kind of irritating and even painful background noise. Think metal rake on a sidewalk, or nails on a chalkbaord.

Consider what “But I trust God” does in that setting. It turns a grieving man’s confession into a contrast between Crystal’s weakness and their steadiness. It answers a wound with a credential. And it was broadcast to millions, about a man who never asked for  their counsel, from a prominent Christian to a grieving Jewish man.

In the Old Testament, Job’s friends get a bad reputation. They did afterall begin well. They sat with him on the ground for seven days and said nothing, “for they saw that his grief was very great” (Job 2:13). Their trouble started when they opened their mouths to defend God. At the end of the book, God rebukes the friends for failing to speak rightly of Him (Job 42:7). The suffering man who shouted at heaven ends the story vindicated, while the men who explained heaven were not.

And in the New Testament, Jesus, standing outside Lazarus’s tomb, knew resurrection was mere minutes away. Yet, he cried anyway (John 11:35). He didn’t open the scene by correcting Martha’s pain when she said, “if you had only been here.” He didn’t say, bad things happen but we should trust God.

The Sound of Silence

So what would a helpful Christian posture look like? Maybe something as simple as this: I’m so sorry. Losing a home of forty-six years and a dear friend in the same year is more than anyone should have to carry. If you can’t talk to God right now, He can hear the silence too. We’re praying for you, and we’re grateful you’re still making people laugh.

That doesn’t water down the gospel. It ornaments it. The cross is not an argument that suffering is fine. It is God stepping inside suffering, forsaken and crying out the opening line of Psalm 22. A Christ who asked “why have you forsaken me?” can surely make room for a comedian who says “I don’t trust God.”

Another option is to say nothing out loud, nothing on line. Maybe just offer a quiet prayer on their behalf. And if you personally know someone suffering, sit with them and let your presence reassure them you care.

Crystal hasn’t stopped laughing, and he hasn’t stopped telling the truth either. In 700 Sundays he talked to God; in 860 he talks about why he can’t. I’d rather he say that honestly on a Broadway stage than recite a pious answer he doesn’t feel. Honest doubt is far closer to prayer than insincere platitudes.

blog Theolatte blends philosophy, theology, and cultural apologetics — steeped in the spirit of C.S. Lewis, Dorothy Sayers, and G.K. Chesterton. SHOP CREATIVE home © THEOLATTE 2026 PODCAST scholar leaders